Old Bridge, New JerseyKnights country · 2026

What is the best pizza in old bridge

14 pizzerias. One favorite.

Checking voting…

Old Bridge, then and now

  1. 1869Founded as Madison Township, named for President James Madison.
  2. 1975Voters rename it Old Bridge, after the first bridge across the South River.
  3. 1994Cedar Ridge and Madison Central merge into Old Bridge High School, home of the Knights.
  4. 2026The town settles its biggest question: who makes the best pie?

An independent community poll. Not affiliated with Old Bridge Township Public Schools or any pizzeria.

Made by Site Rehab

Make your vote count.

Your pick:

Log in with Facebook to save your pick. One account, one vote.

Continue with Facebook

Nothing is posted to Facebook. We only use your email to send you the results.

A purple knight presenting a pizza for the Old Bridge pizza vote.

Vote saved

Spread the pizza love.

Invite your friends to pick their favorite pizzeria.

Facebook